***Place your orders now for New Year’s!***
The holiday season is a special time at the bakeshop. The smells, flavors and smiles all celebrate the magic. Because holiday time is such a busy time in our bakery we feature a holiday menu. Pre-orders are advised and we will place a cut-off date as we near capacity for what our kitchen is able to handle. While we will have extras available in the shop throughout the holiday, it will be on a first come, first serve basis.
Our pies are one of the most requested items that we sell at holiday time. Our menu reflects the most popular flavors at the holiday. While we may have other flavors available in the shop that are not reflected here, the items available for pre-order are on this menu. Place orders on this website in Shop for Pick-up, by calling the shop or stopping in.
Have a wonderful holiday season!
12/25 thru 12/26 CLOSED for the holiday
12/27 - 12/29 normal hours
12/30 10 am to 4 pm
1/1 - 1/3 CLOSED for the holiday
Our pies are pretty fantastic because they taste like home. We learned all about pie making from our grandparents. They lived farm to table---from growing the fruit to rolling their own crust. Our pie crust is still made in small batches with real Wisconsin butter. Our bakers hand-roll our crusts and then we lovingly fill each one with fresh ingredients. If you've gotten our pies at the holiday you know how much fun the bakery is when you stop in and see all the boxes---or pass by our window to watch us burning the midnight oil! We typically cut-off pre-orders a few weeks before the holiday, so don't wait until the last minute!
Apple Crumble: We always use real fruit—-just ask our apple peelers a/k/a bakers! Our apple pie is made using two varieties of apples coated in a cinnamon sugar mixture. We use cinnamon sourced from our local spice company. Apples are placed into our homemade butter crust. The pie is topped with an old-fashioned oat and brown sugar crumble (no nuts).
Apple Cranberry Crumble: Our apple pie is accented with tart cranberries giving the pie a flavor similar to cherry!
Pumpkin: We use the recipe handed down to us by our Grandma—-pumpkin is scented with traditional holiday spices, heavily creamed and placed in a butter crust.
Cowboy Pie: Big, beautiful walnuts and Callebaut dark chocolate chips are the star of this pie! A traditional brown sugar filling gets an upgrade with whiskey—-all surrounded by a buttery crust then drizzled with our homemade fudge.
French Silk: This has become a customer favorite at Christmas! A chocolate mousse filling topped with our homemade whipped cream. (Note: Mousse is traditionally made with raw eggs).
Salty Honey: Another TSP signature favorite! We use honey from Heritage Prairie Farm in Geneva to create a honey custard that is accented with shaved sea salt.
Peppermint: We start with a chocolate cookie crust then add a white peppermint filling studded with Andes mints. We drizzle the top with our homemade fudge.
**Pie Crust and Pie Dough also available for order**
Have us roll it for you or roll your own at home. Our pie dough is available pre-formed and frozen (just add your filling and bake) or in round chilled balls to be taken home and used as you like. Each ball of dough will render two single crusts (for pumpkin or custard pies) or one double crust (for fruit pies). We often have these available—-just stop in or reserve yours here on this site and we will have it ready for you.
All of our cakes are handmade in small batches with real ingredients, no preservatives and no artificial flavorings. All of our cakes are covered in our signature buttercream made with only three ingredients: Real Wisconsin butter, high quality Nielsen Massey Vanilla and powdered sugar (really, that's it!) Any of our Signature Artisan cakes are available for order on the holidays. However, the following cakes would be particularly lovely on your holiday tables:
Pumpkin cake layered with cinnamon buttercream then covered in a caramel drizzle.
Chocolate cake with our signature vanilla buttercream, hot fudge, caramel and pecans.
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
Pumpkin cake with bittersweet chocolate chips covered in chocolate buttercream.
Our Coconut is one of our most popular cakes! Coconut cake layered with coconut buttercream and sweetened coconut flakes.
Cupcakes are one of the most popular items we sell in our shop! Our cupcakes are smaller versions of our cakes and make the perfect sized treat for dessert. If you are eating your cupcakes on Thursday we strongly recommend that you pick your cupcakes up on Wednesday. Cupcakes are little cakes that are not completely covered in frosting meaning they do not stay as moist as cakes for as long as cakes. We bake your cupcakes on the day you pick them up and place them into our plastic containers in order to preserve their quality. Order any quantity from our holiday menu:
Scarlett Red Velvet
Milk n Cookies
Peanut Butter Cookie
Wheat-Free Chocolate (We use Bob's Red Mill Gluten-free flour however our kitchen is not wheat free).
Packages of mini cupcakes are one of our most requested items. Minis are sold already pre-packaged in four flavors OR order your favorites in quantities of a dozen per flavor.
All of our cookies are handmade in small batches as well. We have a variety of homestyle favorites (one size) as well as decorated sugar cookies. For the holiday season we are offering the following cookie menu. Order in quantities of a dozen or pick up one of our pre-packaged gifts. The cookies in gift boxes will come individually heat sealed in bags and will stay fresh for up to two weeks.
Signature Homestyle flavors:
Always available---order by the dozen of each or a combo.
Cracked Sugar with Buttercream dollop
Flourless Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
Christmas Decorated Sugar Cookies
Holiday Plaques (Happy Holidays, Enjoy, etc)
***We may have additional designs in the shop—stop in!
Don’t fret over what to feed the gang in the morning while you’re cooking the big feast. We have many selections to help you out, from morning Quiche (with a Take n Bake option) to Pastries. Pick up one of our breakfast boxes and stay on schedule with your meal prep!
Sugar Sister Quiche
Our Quiche comes in two flavors: Cheese and Veggie. Veggie is made with Cheese, Green Peppers,Tomatoes and Spinach. Quiche can be ordered Take n Bake (comes frozen and you bake at home). Please specify your preference when ordering.
This holiday’s flavors are as follows:
Do-Cup flavors include Old-Fashioned Vanilla Bean, Maple Pecan and Cookies n Cream
Scones include: Cranberry Orange and Maple Pecan
Muffins include: Banana Chocolate Chip and Pumpkin
Just what is a Do-Cup???
We love cupcakes. . .and donuts. So we decided to make a baked cake modeled after donut flavors. All of our Do-Cups start with the softest buttermilk cake and then dipped or filled. Old-fashioned is rolled in powdered sugar and then dipped in a thick vanilla bean glaze. We have lots of flavors—-just like the donut case! Some get filled with chocolate, drizzled in maple glaze and even topped with bacon, or cookies! What’s your favorite?