Sugar Path Bakery

Handcrafted Stylish Sweets


Our Winter daily hours:

Tuesday thru Saturday

10 am to 5 pm

The Sugar Path is a bakery specializing in stylish sweets.  We handcraft our pastries and desserts using a smallbatch method using the finest ingredients. Our retail shop in downtown Geneva, Illinois features a rotating menu of Cakes, Pies, Cupcakes, Cookies, Do-Cups, morning pastries and more.  We specialize in weddings and parties---for a portfolio of our wedding cakes click on the Weddings tab.  We also ship bakery gifts nationwide---go to our online shop at  Connect with us socially @thesugarpath and share by using #thesugarpath

 Our famous Cowboy Pie

Our famous Cowboy Pie


Who doesn't love pie?  In our family it was a time-honored tradition to make pie for family gatherings.  Pie is the type of dessert that causes people to put their busy lives on pause; to sit down at the table and linger over it with a steaming mug of coffee; to strike up family conversations.  We love pie for so many reasons. . .let our pies become a part of your family traditions too.

a note about our pie rotation. . .

We know you love pie and have your favorites. . .we do too.  Unfortunately we have a small kitchen and storage space and cannot stock all the ingredients necessary for every single pie flavor.  The menu on this page represents the pies that can be ordered with 48 hours notice.  If you need pie for a special event or large order--please contact us.  We also ship pie if you are interested in gifting!

Please keep in mind we bake seasonal to always bring you the best!  This means we bake with what is fresh and in season (no cherry or peach or strawberry rhubarb in the fall and winter, sorry!)  If you can't get it fresh at the farm, we can't either!  We do not use canned fruit.

Our pies are available on a rotating basis in our shop.  We serve pie by the slice in our shop.  If you would like to ensure a whole pie, please place an order with 48 hours notice. 

We offer four pie flavors per month.  Our rotation changes monthly.  We also offer our signature pies available by order.  




WE DO NOT ACCEPT ORDERS VIA EMAIL (but you can contact us via email for events, large orders, wholesale and questions).  If ordering just a few pies---We accept orders in the following ways:

In the shop when you drop by

Over the phone when you call us at 630-262-3353

Through our online shop


***If you are ordering pies for a company, large event or wedding, please contact our event managers by calling (630) 882-2536 or email

Pie Order Menu

9 inch Whole Pies

Custard $22/ Cream $24 / Fruit $26 / Chocolate $24 / Nut $32

We feature four or more flavors monthly on our menu.  

Pies of the month can be ordered in any quantity.  


Current Pie Menu


DAILY QUICHE:  Cheese and Veggie


2/21 to 2/28:

Chocolate Chess

Key Lime

Berry Buttermilk


March Menu:

Coconut Buttermilk

Banana Cream

Salty Honey

Peanut Butter Cream on Oreo Crust


PI Day Menu (3.14)

Banana Cream

Salty Honey

Berry Buttermilk

Chocolate Chess

Key Lime


Cheese Quiche

Veggie Quiche


Easter Menu:

Coconut Buttermilk

Banana Cream

Peanut Butter Cream on Oreo Crust

Salty Honey

Salted Caramel Chocolate Chess

Key Lime





Have pie needs we can help you with?  Let's chat!  Just fill out this form and one of our pie specialists will get in touch soon! (Please use for Business, Wholesale or Large Catering orders---not intended for general orders.  Large orders = more than 100 pies.)

Name *
Type of Inquiry
Are you a
wholesale, event, pie-pop up, gifting, large order, etc

Make pie at home. . .

Pie means home to us.  We love hearing how we inspire our customers to bake their own creations at home.  The one thing we hear time after time is that making the crust is often the hurdle that keeps you from baking your own pies.  

We're here to help!  You can now purchase pie dough, formed pie crusts and take n bake items from our freezer!  So get out those rolling pins, roll up those sleeves and start throwing a little flour around the kitchen!

Sugar Path Pie.jpg
 Our Classic Apple Pie #thesugarpath

Our Classic Apple Pie #thesugarpath

Fruit Pies

We bake seasonal using fresh fruit, never canned.  We source fruit from farmers and vendors that we know.  Because of this, our supply of fruit pies is based on the fruit available to us in season.  For fruit pie availability, please call the shop.  Here's a general guideline as to what's in season in Illinois that we bake with:

Spring and Summer:  Strawberries, Rhubarb, Raspberries, Blackberries, Blueberries, Cherries, Peaches, Nectarines, Plums, Apricots, 

Fall and Winter:  Apples, Pears, Figs, Cranberries, 


Mini and Individual Size Pies

We bake mini pies (5 inches, perfect for sharing) and individual sized pies (perfect for events).  These sizes are custom order with a minimum order quantity.  Any of our pie flavors are available as mini pies or individual pies.  For mini pies please order in quantities of four, all the same flavor.  For individual pies, please order in quantities of twelve, all the same flavor.  

Mini Cream and Custard Pies. . .$6 -6.50 each

Mini Chocolate and Nut Pies. . .$7 each

Individual Pies (Tiny Tarts). . .$3 .00 -4.00 each

****Tiny Tarts can be bagged individually for an extra  $.25 and sealed with our label or yours.  Ribbon is an extra charge depending on type of ribbon desired.  


Special Requests

We love pie and you can often find unique flavors in our shop weekly.  Our order menu represents the pies most requested by our customers, and streamlines the ingredients we obtain.  If you have special requests (sometimes a family favorite you want us to make for you) please call us to discuss it.    

and a note about our pie crust. . .

We hand craft all of our crusts with real ingredients and do not use lard.  We refer to our crust as the Triple R (Rissa's Ready to Roll) named after our sweet sister Rissa who helps as a baker in our kitchen and spends numerous hours every week making dough for us.  The Triple R can be purchased from us so that you can make your own pie at home.  

Triple R Pie Dough Ball. . .$12

(Makes 2 Single Crusts or One Double Crust)




Copyright © 2017 The Sugar Path LLC  all rights reserved. The Sugar Path® is a federally registered trademark of The Sugar Path, LLC.   No part of this publication may be reproduced or used without the specific permission of the owner. For permission request write to the publisher: The Sugar Path, 315 W. State Street, Geneva, IL 60134 (630)-262-3353.

Follow us on Social to keep up with what we're doing!